Taylor, Virginia Christine (2003) BALLERINAS IN THE CHURCH HALL: IDEOLOGIES OF FEMININITY, BALLET, AND DANCING SCHOOLS. Doctoral thesis, University of Chichester.

[img] Text

Download (10MB)


The 'Church Hall' is a metonym for the Private Dancing School, ubiquitous in the UK,
whose principal clients are young girls. The thesis interrogates the notion that taking part in
ballet is a capitulation to the 'stereotypically feminine', by analysing the testimony of girls
aged between 8 and II who attend local dancing schools. It presents their comparative
assessment of the pedagogies in their primary schools and dancing classes. The thesis
interrogates the stability of the idea of 'feminine' and its relationship with the political
position of women, employing the theoretical, conceptual foundation for the obverse of a
phallogocentric value system developed by psychiatrist Ian D.Suttie (1935), and the
possibilities of loosening binary oppositions offered by the semiotic (Greimas') square. The
thesis also proposes that the 'symbolic spread' (Frye, 1976: 59) of ballet, and hostility to it,
are cognate with the concerns, dynamics, and reception of literary romance, and that both are
perceived by the 'guardians oftaste and learning' (Northrop Frye's phrase, 1976:23) in terms
which demonstrate Suttie's 'taboo on tenderness'.
The thesis brings into representation the history and relationship to the state of
British dance culture's 'Private Sector', in dialectical relationship to the largely negative
terms in which it is cast by the academic dance community and the maintained education
sector. The thesis challenges most private dance schools' exclusion from access to an
authentic ballet 'text' by arguing it to be, like ballet's history in the working theatre,
marginalised on ideological as much as artistic grounds. It recognises the place of the
dancing class in social history, and presently, as a locus of social capital (Putnam, 2000) and,
with reference to information from parents and popular culture, as a 'Women's Room'
(French, 1977).
The study is in part ethnographic, in part literary criticism, and in part historical; it
considers representations in fiction, criticism, historiography, and other sources; it also
draws on research in cultural and critical theory, education, anthropology, the history of art,
sociology, hermeneutics, and other philosophy. It is post-positivist and qualitative. Neither
its historical and social findings, nor its theoretical approach, have appeared before in the
critical record.

Item Type: Thesis (Doctoral)
Uncontrolled Keywords: Dance, Ideology, Feminism, Ballet
Subjects: G Geography. Anthropology. Recreation > GV Recreation Leisure > GV1580 Dance
Divisions: Departments > Dance
Depositing User: Steve Bowman
Date Deposited: 19 Nov 2015 09:49
Last Modified: 19 Nov 2015 09:49

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item